Simple Modern 40 oz Tumbler with Handle

Keeps water decently cold, although ice doesn't seem to last as long as in my other tumblers. The leak proof feature is nice, but if the lid isn't on 100% correctly it will seep just a little bit along the edge. Also, there are times when water comes out of the top part of the straw after closed. Not a leak, just a bit of a gotcha. Remember to sip the remaining water out after closing it and you're fine. These are the good things, however in my opinion the negatives outweigh the bad. It's dishwasher safe, but too tall to fit upright in the top rack of my dishwasher, even with it on the lowest setting. Kind of negates the point of being dishwasher safe. It's also too tall to fit properly in my fridge ice/water dispenser. This makes filling it properly full a challenge. All of my neat and cute straw toppers don't fit because the silicone portion of the straw is much larger. Total bummer IMO. If you carry your tumbler around all the time having cute accessories is a fun option. From time to time the straw makes a wooshing noise when used. Also, the bottom portion of the straw has disconnected a time or two and had to be fixed to continue using the tumbler. Lastly, and worst in my opinion, this thing is super top heavy. The least little bump and it goes crashing over. I'm a clutz, so this is a bit of a problem. Fortunately it's leak proof, but having a tumbler banging all over constantly isn't fun. I feel like a lot of these cons could be addressed with a more thoughtful design. Making the tumbler slightly shorter but a bit wider on the top to still hold 40 oz sure seems like a plausible fix to most of these. Kind of feel like this is a "do better" situation.