Back to Amazon.com
customer reviews
38,977
4.4 out of 5 stars

Nest Learning Thermostat, 3rd Gen White (Open Box)

$138.22
$249 44% off Reference Price
Condition: New; Open Box
Color: White
Sold out Back to product details

Top positive review
79 people found this helpful
Just an amazing product that saved me 13 grand --- for now
By Breathtaking Vintage on Reviewed in the United States on February 23, 2016
I have a lot of observations to make about this product. I'll start with what I was faced with first.I live in a 2 story house, purchased last July. I live in South Carolina, where it's very humid and we rarely use our heating systems. The heater with air handler is located in the attic. The house was built in 2003. No one has ever replaced the contractor-installed Bryant brand heater. I've had these heaters before, and they are annoying. Whenever I replaced them in the past with a Trane furnace, my bill was cut in half and none of the ridiculous traits of the Bryant happened anymore. Those being the following: Cold spots in different places all over the house. A long ignite time, which means it's blowing cold air on you from the vents before it finally ignites. Too long to ignite. Uneven heating everywhere. Too hot upstairs, too cold downstairs. When the temps got below 35, it was unbearable downstairs unless I cranked it up to 70, which is a high temp for me on the thermostat in the winter.My AC condenser was replaced recently, so in the summer the air conditioner handled everything very well. It is a 4 ton unit and unrelated brand to the Bryant. (not a very good plan, but at least the AC works well). The AC has none of the issues that the furnace has. It works great.There's a problem, though. Because past owners pieced together a different AC system, the two systems are not as efficient as they could be. They also just can't put in a furnace and make it all work. Not the kind of efficiency furnace I've bought before.I just needed a furnace, but not an AC unit. So, I set out to talk to all these Trane installers. I love the two stage AC units from Trane because they only go into the higher mode when they really have to. The answer I got?"You can't change out only one unit. It has to be both." (something I knew from previous houses, anyway).Installer: "That's going to cost you $13,000.00"Me: "Gulp. I know that they really need to both be married up, in order for them to work well."Installer: "No other way, with this pieced together system you have right now."The problem with this? I didn't have the cash. Lowes would only loan me $6,000 at no interest. I always went for no interest loans in the past. Wells Fargo would only give me 5,700.00 but I could not combine both of these financing options. No one would loan me (or anyone else) that much money. I could've gone with a personal line of credit at my bank, but it was 10 - 12 %. Banks are a lot tighter with home improvement loans these days, since GE sold its finance division to a company called MySynchrony. GE gave me 15,000.00 no interest for the first year once. Not anymore.So, I set out to get 4 more quotes. Same answer from all of them. So, I was stuck with running downstairs to turn the heat down at night because I felt like I was going to suffocate upstairs, then running downstairs in the morning to turn it up to get it warmer down there.Then I remembered the Nest. It's expensive, yes. But .....it is better to at least try to spend $248.00 instead of 13 grand.(All the quotes I got were pretty much the same.)At the very least, I could incorporate it into a new system in the future.Install: Easiest install of any thermostat I've ever performed. I've always done my own installs because I liked Honeywell for many years, but there are no screws or difficult, cramped holes to put the wires into. You don't have to read a book to figure out which wires to use and guess what kind of system you have. It already knew, once I installed it.It's connected to the Internet through your WIFI. If I'm upstairs with the heat on and it gets too hot up there, I just pick up my iPhone, go to the app and adjust it. If I want to go downstairs in the morning and know I have it set to 65 down there, I just heat it up a bit on my iPhone before I get out of bed.It learns. I'm not quite sure what it will learn from me, because I'm retired and usually keep things about the same. But, the programming was extremely easy, both on the unit and on the iPhone app. Change it anytime I want.I was at the doctor yesterday. Realized that just my dogs were at home and I had started the AC this past weekend. (You can switch between heat and air any time you want on the iPhone or iPad app...awesome. ) So, I just turned up the AC to a warmer temp because my dogs aren't too crazy about it being really cold. Before I got home, I set it back to 70 for AC, where I like it. I was bed-ridden after some spinal injections this past weekend. I was praising this thing for making my life comfortable while I recuperated upstairs. Before, it would've been absolute agony to go downstairs all the time because South Carolina is in Spring already. You never know what the day will be like. I just changed it when I needed to on my iPhone.The WIFI was easy to connect, once I realized that you turn the unit itself with a rotating dial either left or right, then press on the choice you want. No annoying methods to type in your password like it is on a Bluray player to login to an app like Netflix. Those are a pain.The screen is motion-sensing on the unit, so you just have to walk by or wave your hand to see its settings. It seems to also get my systems to the correct temperature WAY faster than my Honeywell thermostat did. Seconds vs minutes.Now: I've saved $13 Grand. For now. It's made my furnace manageable in a two story house. I can save up the cash for a new system. It has a mode called Airwave that is supposed to save you on AC costs. I'll know in July and August if that works well.I believe it's going to save me a lot of money and allow me the time to save up for the new system that I really want. I will have my installers just leave the Nest there. It's an incredible product. I've not found one bug with it yet. It's only been about 5 days, but it is already telling me it is learning.Love this product. So glad I bought it. It's the best piece of technology I've bought so far, besides the iPad Pro.Thank you Nest. You saved me a lot of money for now.A few months later:This product is already saving me a lot of money. It's already saved me $40.00 this month on electric. One thing I wanted to mention was someone was complaining about the way it displays the temperature. I think that it is just a matter of getting used to it because there is a rare occasion that the large number in the middle and the smaller number are not the same. What I've noticed is it gets my system up to the correct temperature way faster, and so I'm really not so concerned with the smaller number anymore.I also saw that someone was complaining about the Away function if you don't walk in front of it often and waking up to a cold house. I'm retired, so I don't really need a regular Away function. I go out at really different times, so I went into the settings on the App and turned that off. Problem solved.I love that my air conditioner doesn't run as much as it used to, and I noticed I don't have as much cold air coming out of the vents when the heater is working.I also get an email of my usage each month from Nest. (see image) The leafs mean you've set your temp to an energy-saving setting and will also show up on the dial.And It's still saved me 13 grand. Win win for me.
Top critical review
52 people found this helpful
Replacement will be a refurbished one from their pile of junk.
By Timothy D. on Reviewed in the United States on May 6, 2023
I copied this from M Strikers review because it is exactly what has happened to me. I was until I had all of this trouble a Google shareholder. I have since sold my shares as I have lost confidence in the company. After reading the reviews it appears that when the Nest works it works well. But when you have an issue they send you a replacement from their collection of broken thermostats. I hope it works for you but be prepared to be without a working thermostat for months if it ever breaks. Save your old thermostat, you may need it. M Striker1.0 out of 5 starsVerified PurchaseThe worst piece of technology I have ever purchasedReviewed in the United States on April 18, 2023Color: Stainless SteelStyle: Thermostat OnlyI purchased a Google Nest 3rd Generation Learning Thermostat in late August of 2022. It worked fine until early January 2023 when it started displaying an error message stating it could not connect to my Wi-Fi network. My wife and I both tried to get it to reconnect and could not get it reconnected to our Wi-Fi network which has a very strong signal. My Wi-Fi network has been the same network during this time, and no other devices in the house including phones, tablets, laptops, printers, cameras and numerous other connected devices have had any Wi-Fi issues during this time. I called Google tech support and they talked me through a bunch of steps including several ‘master reset’ attempts and it did briefly reconnect to the network, but within an hour had disconnected from the Wi-Fi again. I called Google Tech support a 2nd time, and they determined my unit was defective and needed to be replaced. They wanted me to send the thermostat back to them, and then they would send a replacement. Considering it is the middle of winter, and I can’t have a house without a thermostat, I asked for another (faster) option to get their defective unit replaced. They said the only option was to charge credit card for a replacement unit, and then when I returned the defective unit to them, they would remove the charge on my credit card. I reluctantly agreed to this (because I had no other option). When the replacement unit arrived, I discovered it was not a new unit but a ‘reconditioned unit’. When I went to install it, it would not power up, so I called Google Tech Support (3rd call to Google). They helped me to determine that the battery was dead on the replacement unit, and I had to charge the unit on a USB cable before installing it. The next day (after charging it for 24 hours) I tried to install the unit and it again would not make it through the start up menu. It alternated 2 error messages (1. Disconnect unit from the wall 2. Reconnect unit to the wall) depending if the unit was on or off the wall. So, I called Google support again (4th call) and they determined the unit was defective. I requested they send me a brand new unit this time, but I they said that was not their ‘process’ and they would send another refurbished unit. I protested to no avail. They said I would have to send back the defective refurbished unit before they could send me another replacement (All this time I have been using the original Nest from August because it at least functions as a DUMB thermostat, it just can’t connect to Wi-Fi or run schedules). So, I sent the defective refurbished replacement back and then waited almost 2 weeks for them to send another refurbished unit. I think during that time I called Google support 2 more times trying to get the status of the replacement. That 2nd replacement unit arrived 2 days ago, and again the battery was dead. I charged that unit for 1 day, and then reinstalled the unit, and again found it would not make it through the startup menu. It alternated 2 error messages (1. Disconnect unit from the wall 2. Reconnect unit to the wall) depending if the unit was on or off the wall. I again had to call Google tech support who again determined this 2nd replacement unit was defective. I again begged for a new unit, and they again would only send a replacement by charging my credit card again. That third replacement arrived and was another refurbished unit with a dead battery and had to be charged to get it to work. That unit worked from mid-February to unit midmid-April (2 months). However, on the first really warm day, we turned on the AC and our outdoor unit started making a loud clicking noise. I assumed there was something wrong with the motor or fan on the outdoor unit and schedule an HVAC repairman to come diagnose the problem the next business day. That repairman came today and spent about 2 hours troubleshooting the issue and he determined that the Google Nest was not sending a consistent signal to the AC unit causing the outdoor unit fan to intermittently shut off/on repeatedly. Obviously, I had to pay for that service call which was not cheap. I just purchased and installed an EcoBee Thermostat and it, and my HVAC unit are now working fine. I just tried calling Google to ask for a refund for my Nest and the Google Nest Remote temperature sensor, and they have refused to refund my money. They only want to send me yet another refurbished unit, but after all these problems, I am not willing to try that. So now, I am out almost $300 for the Google Nest and the Remote sensor, but also out another $100 for the HVAC service call, and countless hours trying to get the Google Nest to work. This is absolutely the worst piece of technology that I have ever purchased. Google’s tech support was completely inflexible to offer any solutions other than just more refurbished units. If I could have rated this product lower, I would have.

Sort by:
Filter by:
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews


people found this helpful
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product