Hey Dude Men's Wally Stretch Fleece (Open Box)

VERY LONG REVIEW/ BUT SIZE IMPORTANT!!! My husband wears a size 14 in all shoes. His actual size is more like a 13.5 but most shoes in those sizes don't half size, so he rounds up. We've never had an issue with him buying a size 14 shoe and it not fitting. He's never had a pair of hey dudes, though I own 6 pairs bought from brick and mortar stores with genuine hey dudes. I wear a size 9 to a 9.5 in other shoes (comfortably) but in Hey Dudes, I fit size 9 with zero issues, plenty of room with socks or without. His first pair we bought here on Amazon - in a size 14 - were INCREDIBLY tight. They only go to a 15, we sent the first pair back and ordered these in a 15. And, to be honest, they are tighter than he'd like, and he's worried that his toes will eventually wear out the tops, but we kept this last pair. In the box, it has a sizing guide. I put my foot in and - as expected - it put me right at the size 8, but with room for socks or bare foot, a size 9 would be perfect (as my store bought hey dudes are). We did my husbands and it showed his foot right at the size 12 - crazy enough. Meaning, a size 13 would be his perfect size and the size 15's would be a whole 3 sizes too large, but the 14's was insanely tight and the 15's aren't much better. I also bought me a pair from this same seller, in my regular size 9's and they are pretty tight. I can't wear socks with them at all. I like the color and I haven't seen that particular pair anywhere else and the other sizes are sold out, so I'm keeping mine, too. But I have to say, if this is the actual Hey Dude sellers, they might be selling the misfits here on Amazon, because there is NO WAY we would randomly get 3 pairs incorrectly sized on pure 'bad luck'. It's sad, too, because there were a TON of colors and patterns I wanted and can't be found elsewhere and I wanted to get my husband a few more pairs to match clothing, but I won't do it again, because there is no telling what size we do or don't need since it's so out of wack.