Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner, Indigo

This has been my favorite eyeliner for most of a decade now. Yes, in mulberry--I have green eyes and this looks great (and subtle) with natural eyeshadow tones. I have gotten compliments from everyone who notices it. "Is that purple eyeliner?!? It looks great!!! What is it?!?" It's not boldly purple but if you have green eyes and wear a lot of natural-toned eyeshadow, this is an excellent choice. This liner doesn't really smudge at all... but if you want to, you *can* soften it a bit with a fingertip *immediately* after application. But eyeshadow brushes don't usually affect it and, once it has had a minute or two to set, I usually need micellar water or makeup remover to edit it.