Back to Amazon.com
customer reviews
78,120
4.4 out of 5 stars

Cookies & Cream 12ct Quest Protein Bar

$17.97
$28.63 37% off Reference Price
Condition: New
Model: Cookies & Cream
Sold out Back to product details

Top positive review
11 people found this helpful
Best Birthday Cake Flavored Protein Bar I've Tried
By Baxter on Reviewed in the United States on April 20, 2025
Something about the idea of "birthday cake flavor" really activates my neurons, so much so that I've undertaken a side quest to determine the best tasting birthday cake flavored/branded bar, and to my surprise, it's this one. I say surprise because I had a quest bar variety pack a while ago and all the normal quest bar flavors in there were kinda mid. Best protein/calorie ratio of any brand besides David though. But yeah I've tried the birthday cake flavor from: Rule 1/Bar 1, One, Pure Protein, Barebell, David ('cake batter' technically), and Quests crispy birthday cake bar, but this one right here seems to be the goat. Lacks the chemical taste birthday cake flavoring seems to have sometimes (also tried birthday cake extract/flavoring which had those chemy vibes), the Pure Protein and Bar1 birthday cake bars suffer from that pretty significantly and barebells flavor to a lesser extent. The interior of this bar is soft and moist in a way reminiscent of what you'd expect from something cake-y, and the white-chocolate (or whatever it actually is) coating is pretty good and not weird as well. The runners up are probably the Quest Crunch Birthday Cake bar in a close second place, and Ones take in 3rd. The barebell one is worth at least trying if you're really into the birthday cake flavor idea. The rest are kind of trash tbh (respect to David for the great macros though, I would get those more if I wasn't poor lol. And Pure Proteins salted caramel is one of my favorite things to eat period so not trashing the other brands in general here). Essentially, if you seek a good birthday cake flavored bar, you need look no further (unless you have a thing for rice crispy treats or that kinda vibe, then definitely try the Quest Crispy Birthday Cake bar as well. Maybe the Bar 1 bar as well, was like a big rice crispy treat but flavor was slightly questionable, not too bad though.)
Top critical review
1 people found this helpful
a bit sickly sweet, my second box so far they seem to make me feel a bit sick on eating
By DeltaPeng on Reviewed in the United States on August 14, 2025
generally tasty, particularly for a protein bar, but a bit sickly sweet downrated, bc second box I bought after eating it I feel a bit sick. Idk what it is, but I got it fresh from amazon subscribe, so it shouldn't have been an issue with expiration of ingredients. So, now I have like 3/4 of the box sitting around, and I'm unsure if I should just toss it out or not I suspect quality control if this happens, so bc of sickly sweetness and low quality control, I have stopped purchasing

Sort by:
Filter by:
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews


people found this helpful
By -
Verified Amazon Purchase
Vine Customer Review of Free Product